A. Overall Composition
Look at the sculpture from every angle. First of all, are the proportions right -- be especially critical with bears and people; seals, walrus & birds are less likely to be out of proportion as they are much simpler subject matter to carve.
Next, look at the overall shape and determine whether you find it appealing. Sensuous rounded curves should flow and be very tactile. Conversely, if the piece is intentionally angular, it should be boldly so.
Finally, stand back and look at the sculpture; does it have "movement" in form? Neither people nor mammals should be rigid or static. This shows a lack of skill or creativity by the artist. The exception, of course, is inanimate objects such as inuksuks. In a composition piece, all subjects must work together to strengthen the sculpture. You must see a relationship between the subjects and understand how each adds to the work of art. With composition pieces, it is especially important that you view it "in the round" as it, no doubt, will be seen from several perspectives.